نوع مقاله : مستخرج از پایان نامه
عنوان مقاله English
نویسندگان English
The concept of women-friendly city focuses on developing safe, accessible, and inclusive urban environments that address women's needs and everyday experiences. This study aims to evaluate the desirability of the urban environment in Ardabil and investigate the relationships among the three principal dimensions of a women-friendly city. The research adopted an applied, descriptive-analytical approach. A 55-item questionnaire was completed by 400 systematically randomly sampled women in Ardabil (Cronbach's α = 0.935; content validity via CVR). Data were analyzed in SPSS and AMOS using descriptive statistics, one-sample t-tests, Pearson correlation, and structural equation modeling. The findings revealed mean scores of 2.37 for the physical-environmental dimension, 2.36 for the socio-cultural dimension, and 2.44 for the accessibility dimension. All three scores fell below the theoretical benchmark of 3, with the differences being statistically significant (p < 0.001). Substantial positive correlations were also identified between the physical-environmental and socio-cultural dimensions (r = 0.643), the physical-environmental and accessibility dimensions (r = 0.580), and the socio-cultural and accessibility dimensions (r = 0.667) (p < 0.001). In the estimated structural model, the standardized coefficient for the socio-cultural dimension was 0.89, whereas the physical-environmental and accessibility dimensions were both 0.82. Nevertheless, the Comparative Fit Index (CFI = 0.672) and the Incremental Fit Index (IFI = 0.675) indicated a relatively poor overall model fit. Overall, the findings point to an undesirable condition across all three dimensions of the women-friendly city framework in Ardabil. Urban planning should prioritize better public spaces, safety and lighting, women's participation, and service access.
Extended Abstract
Introduction
The quality of urban environments plays an important role in shaping women's everyday experiences, opportunities for social participation, and access to urban facilities. A women-friendly city is not defined solely by the availability of physical infrastructure; rather, it encompasses a combination of environmental quality, safety, accessibility, socio-cultural conditions, and opportunities for women to participate independently in urban life. Rapid urbanization and persistent structural and cultural barriers have further underscored the importance of developing inclusive urban environments that respond to the needs of diverse social groups, particularly women.
Previous studies have highlighted the importance of public-space quality, urban safety, transportation, environmental lighting, route legibility, and place attachment in shaping women's experiences of urban environments. Research studies have also emphasized the relationship among urban design, accessibility, and social participation in the development of gender-inclusive cities . These findings suggest that women's assessment of urban environments depends on several interconnected factors rather than on physical characteristics alone. In Ardabil, previous research has examined selected women-friendly city indicators and the relationship between urban environmental conditions and women's psychological well-being. Nasiri et al. (2025) reported that some indicators of women-friendly urban environments were below desirable levels. Subsequent research by Nasiri et al. (2026) highlighted the importance of physical and spatial conditions, environmental safety, socio-cultural factors, and accessibility in relation to women's psychological well-being. Nevertheless, an integrated assessment of urban environmental desirability across these dimensions and an examination of their interrelationships remain necessary.More than half of the world’s population lives in urban areas, and this proportion is expected to increase to 70% by 2050. Rapid urbanization, particularly in developing countries, has created considerable challenges for vulnerable groups, including women. In response to these challenges, the United Nations introduced the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development in 2016, placing particular emphasis on the importance of creating safe and inclusive public spaces for women. Nevertheless, despite these global commitments, women continue to be disproportionately affected by various urban challenges. In many societies, including Iran, structural and cultural barriers continue to restrict women’s access to public spaces.Urban public spaces constitute an essential part of the urban structure and serve as settings for social interactions, collective activities, and the formation of citizens’ identities. These spaces are considered to have a desirable level of quality when they provide easy accessibility, comfort, sociability, and a diversity of activities. From Habermas’s (1962) perspective, the public sphere provides a platform for social interaction and participation in collective life. However, opportunities to benefit from urban spaces are not equally distributed among all social groups. Environmental and social characteristics can influence citizens’ sense of security, participation, and well-being, particularly among women.
Accordingly, the present study aims to assess the desirability of urban environments in Ardabil based on three dimensions: physical-environmental conditions, socio-cultural conditions, and accessibility. It also examines the relationships among these dimensions. The central research questions concern the extent to which Ardabil's urban environments are desirable in each dimension and whether significant relationships exist among them. The study hypothesizes that the three dimensions are positively and significantly correlated. By examining these dimensions together, the study seeks to provide empirical evidence in order to support more inclusive and gender-responsive urban planning.
Methodology
This study employed a descriptive-analytical research design using library research and a field survey. The statistical population comprised women residing in Ardabil, with a reported population of 292,997. Based on Cochran’s formula, 400 participants were selected through systematic random sampling. Data were collected using a researcher-developed questionnaire consisting of 55 items measured on a five-point Likert scale. Construct validity was examined through confirmatory factor analysis, and reliability was assessed using Cronbach’s alpha, which yielded an overall coefficient of 0.935. Data were analyzed using SPSS and AMOS through a one-sample t-tests, Pearson’s correlation analysis, and structural equation modeling. The findings indicated that the desirability of Ardabil’s urban environment was below the theoretical benchmark of 3 in all three dimensions: physical-environmental conditions (2.37), socio-cultural conditions (2.36), and accessibility (2.44). These differences were statistically significant (p < 0.001). Positive and statistically significant correlations were also found among all three dimensions. The strongest correlation was observed between the socio-cultural and accessibility dimensions (r = 0.667), whereas the weakest correlation was found between the physical-environmental and accessibility dimensions (r = 0.580). However, the structural equation model exhibited limited overall fit, as reflected in the CFI (0.672) and IFI (0.675) values; therefore, its coefficients should be interpreted cautiously. Overall, the findings highlight the unsatisfactory status of all three dimensions and emphasize the need to address physical-environmental quality, socio-cultural conditions, and women's access to urban services and public spaces simultaneously in women-friendly urban planning.
Results and Discussion
The results indicate that Ardabil's urban environment remains insufficiently responsive to women's needs across the physical-environmental, socio-cultural, and accessibility dimensions. Mean scores below the theoretical benchmark suggest that women's urban experiences are shaped by environmental quality, safety, independent mobility, access to services, and social participation. These findings are consistent with national studies highlighting shortcomings in public-space quality, safety, urban services, and transportation (Farahzad et al., 2020; Rezaei et al., 2023; Garmisrinejad et al., 2021; Taheri et al., 2021). Research studies have also emphasized the importance of lighting, route legibility, and place attachment in women's urban safety (Rousta & Ahmadi, 2019; Amani et al., 2019).
The low mean score for the physical-environmental dimension suggests that urban spaces may not fully satisfy women's needs. This finding aligns with Gehl's (2011) emphasis on public-space quality, walkability, and conditions supporting social activities. Inadequate pedestrian facilities, poor maintenance, and insufficient amenities may reduce the usability of urban spaces. However, further analysis of individual indicators is needed to identify specific environmental shortcomings.
The socio-cultural dimension received the lowest mean score, highlighting the importance of social experiences and cultural contexts alongside physical design. Women's use of public spaces may be shaped by factors such as perceived safety, social interaction, place attachment, and opportunities for participation. Preceding studies have similarly emphasized the relationships between environmental conditions, gender equality, and participation in urban life (Middleton, 2016; Yadav & Kumari, 2021; Efe Güney et al., 2023). Nevertheless, the mean score alone cannot establish specific cultural or social causes.
Accessibility recorded the highest mean among the three dimensions, but remained below the theoretical benchmark. Thus, it represents a relative strength rather than a desirable condition. Improving access to services, reducing mobility barriers, and ensuring convenient and independent use of public spaces remain important planning priorities.
Positive correlations among the three dimensions further demonstrate their interconnectedness. The strongest relationship was found between socio-cultural conditions and accessibility, followed by physical-environmental and socio-cultural conditions. These associations suggest that access to facilities, environmental quality, and social participation are related in everyday urban life; however, they do not establish causality. Furthermore, the low CFI and IFI values indicate limitations in the structural equation model's fit, requiring cautious interpretation of its coefficients. Overall, the findings reinforce the importance of integrated women-friendly urban planning that addresses public-space quality, safety, accessibility, and socio-cultural inclusion while accounting for Ardabil's local conditions.
Conclusion
This study assessed the desirability of urban environments in Ardabil from the perspective of three dimensions of the women-friendly city framework: physical-environmental conditions, socio-cultural conditions, and accessibility. The results exhibited that all three dimensions fell below the theoretical benchmark of 3, indicating that the urban environment was not considered sufficiently desirable across the dimensions examined. The socio-cultural dimension recorded the lowest mean score, whereas accessibility had the highest mean, although neither reached the benchmark. The statistically significant positive correlations among the three dimensions indicate that they are associated and should be considered together in urban planning. The findings support an integrated approach that combines improvements in the physical environment with attention to women's social experiences and access to urban facilities. However, the limitations identified in the structural model's fit indices mean that its coefficients should be interpreted cautiously and that further model assessment is warranted. From a practical perspective, urban planners and local authorities should prioritize improving the quality and maintenance of public spaces, enhancing lighting and safety, facilitating access to urban services, and supporting women's participation in urban planning and design processes. These measures should be informed by the specific needs and experiences of women in different neighborhoods of Ardabil. Rather than relying exclusively on the provision of infrastructure, planning should also consider whether women can access and use public spaces safely, comfortably, and independently.
Several limitations should be considered when interpreting the findings. First, the study was conducted exclusively in Ardabil, which may limit the generalizability of the results to other cities. Second, difficulties in accessing some up-to-date urban statistics may have constrained the analysis. Third, cultural and social circumstances may have influenced respondents' willingness to express their experiences and views concerning women's presence in public spaces. Finally, the study focused on three dimensions and therefore did not encompass every factor potentially relevant to women-friendly urban environments.
Future studies should apply and validate the proposed framework in cities with different physical, social, and cultural characteristics. Comparative studies could clarify which challenges are shared across urban contexts and which are specific to individual cities. Further investigations could also incorporate economic conditions, urban management policies, and social capital. In addition, in-depth interviews with women and urban managers, longitudinal studies, and evaluations of specific urban policies could provide a more comprehensive understanding of changes in women's urban experiences over time. In conclusion, the study highlights the need to integrate physical-environmental quality, socio-cultural inclusion, and accessibility into efforts to create women-friendly cities. Addressing these dimensions collectively may help urban authorities develop environments that better support women's safety, independence, participation, and everyday use of public spaces in Ardabil.
کلیدواژهها English